Water pump replacement - Should I?
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Water pump replacement - Should I?
Hi all,
I'm getting prepared to do belts/rollers and cam pad/chain work in the next couple of weeks.
My water pump was changed at 80k kms roughly 10 years ago - car now has 89k kms.
I know the easy answer is yes but it's very easy to get all ocd with the "while you're in there" work.
What does the 968 trust say? yay or nay?
TIA
I'm getting prepared to do belts/rollers and cam pad/chain work in the next couple of weeks.
My water pump was changed at 80k kms roughly 10 years ago - car now has 89k kms.
I know the easy answer is yes but it's very easy to get all ocd with the "while you're in there" work.
What does the 968 trust say? yay or nay?
TIA
#3
Are you your own mechanic? If so I'd likely skip it. Sounds like you are not too worried about the car stranding you somewhere when the water pump goes out.
In my case the mechanc usually convinced me to do the water pump every timing belt or two since they would be right there anyways. I'm having the water pump done now while they are doing the timing belt on my low mileage car. I'd guess that car will get less miles than yours is getting now the next 10 yrs. I think I'll wait longer than that time wise before I'll redo the timing belt, but I guess when I do I'll have them do the water pump too.
Btw I guess I'm one of the few here that has had their timing belt go out while driving. I was idling at a stop light. Let out the clutch and the car died. Turned it over a few times and it did not sound like it was going to crank so I called for a tow. I got lucky with no motor damage. How it happened was I had a euro mechanic I used for my Mercedes old Mercedes. The balance belt went and he did not change the timing belt at the same time. Needless to say I never used him again. I used the dealer until I was over 120k miles.
In my case the mechanc usually convinced me to do the water pump every timing belt or two since they would be right there anyways. I'm having the water pump done now while they are doing the timing belt on my low mileage car. I'd guess that car will get less miles than yours is getting now the next 10 yrs. I think I'll wait longer than that time wise before I'll redo the timing belt, but I guess when I do I'll have them do the water pump too.
Btw I guess I'm one of the few here that has had their timing belt go out while driving. I was idling at a stop light. Let out the clutch and the car died. Turned it over a few times and it did not sound like it was going to crank so I called for a tow. I got lucky with no motor damage. How it happened was I had a euro mechanic I used for my Mercedes old Mercedes. The balance belt went and he did not change the timing belt at the same time. Needless to say I never used him again. I used the dealer until I was over 120k miles.
#5
Drifting
once you have the cam belt off, you should be able to somewhat discern the bearings in the pump by observation. any tells of rust from the seal, play or non-smooth rotation would cause concern.
the pump on my car lasted twenty years and failure was a loose composite impeller. throwing ten bucks at a new gasket and digging in a few bolts deeper isn't a bad idea.
the hydraulic tensioner set up is superior to the previous renditions.
the pump on my car lasted twenty years and failure was a loose composite impeller. throwing ten bucks at a new gasket and digging in a few bolts deeper isn't a bad idea.
the hydraulic tensioner set up is superior to the previous renditions.
#6
Rennlist Member
I would say you are okay until your next T-belt change unless you see signs of a leak or hear a bearing noise. 968 water pumps don't have the same issues as 944s. IMHO.
#7
Rennlist Member
I would skip it. I'm going to do the belts on my 951 in a few weeks and the water pump has a similar history, I'm not going to change it. And $450 or so for it, I would definitely skip it.
Trending Topics
#8
Burning Brakes
Yeah, I'd say skip it as well. Given the cost, it isn't exactly cheap insurance. I've had my reman pump for about 7 years with no hint of any issues, so I agree these pumps are pretty stout.
#9
This thread just reminds me how ridiculous some Porsche parts can be. I just went through all this with my Lexus LS430. It's a premium brand similar to Porsche and has its own parts that are sky high, but the entire timing belt kit, including rollers, belts, water pump and everything you need, is $180, all OEM parts.
It would be so much easier to really love my 968 if maintaining the thing from catastrophic failure wasn't so damn expensive!
It would be so much easier to really love my 968 if maintaining the thing from catastrophic failure wasn't so damn expensive!
#10
Rennlist Member
Mileage is so low since new I would just do the visual and if it looks good, leave it till next t-belt change. But don't wait six years, age is just as bad as mileage. And use Gates belts, not Conti.
Porsche dealers have a rebuilt waterpump for under $250 with factory warranty. Still a lot, but better than price for new one.
Porsche dealers have a rebuilt waterpump for under $250 with factory warranty. Still a lot, but better than price for new one.
#11
Registered User
Originally Posted by biosurfer1
This thread just reminds me how ridiculous some Porsche parts can be. I just went through all this with my Lexus LS430. It's a premium brand similar to Porsche and has its own parts that are sky high, but the entire timing belt kit, including rollers, belts, water pump and everything you need, is $180, all OEM parts.
It would be so much easier to really love my 968 if maintaining the thing from catastrophic failure wasn't so damn expensive!
It would be so much easier to really love my 968 if maintaining the thing from catastrophic failure wasn't so damn expensive!
#12
Rennlist Member
It really isn't that bad. The only thing you HAVE to do is the belts every 5 years and if you shop around and provide the parts yourself you can get it done for under a grand (at my local Porsche dealer). For perspective, talk to the owner of that beautiful Ferrari 355!
#14
Rennlist Member
#15
Are the timing belts and balance shaft belts for the 968 not the very same belts that are used on the 951/944 that have a 4 yr/40,000 / 45,000 mile lifespan?
Last edited by spanky; 05-16-2019 at 11:44 AM.