Why is clutch pedal pressure so hard?
#1
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Why is clutch pedal pressure so hard?
Dear All,
Why is the clutch pedal pressure so hard in my '02 C4S compared to the newer cars? Everything is in good operating order, helper spring is there, etc. etc.. But when I drove my friend's 997, I couldn't believe the difference. His pedal pressure was very light, and it simply was a dream to shift. It made mine feel like an old El Camino.
Are there fundamental differences between the two? Different master cylinder, system or what? Anyone know if I can upgrade mine? I'm jealous.
Please. Don't tell me to buy a newer car. I just want to know if anyone out there ever tried anything that helped.
Thanks much,
Steve
Why is the clutch pedal pressure so hard in my '02 C4S compared to the newer cars? Everything is in good operating order, helper spring is there, etc. etc.. But when I drove my friend's 997, I couldn't believe the difference. His pedal pressure was very light, and it simply was a dream to shift. It made mine feel like an old El Camino.
Are there fundamental differences between the two? Different master cylinder, system or what? Anyone know if I can upgrade mine? I'm jealous.
Please. Don't tell me to buy a newer car. I just want to know if anyone out there ever tried anything that helped.
Thanks much,
Steve
#5
Newbies Hospitality Director
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Winston-Salem, NC
Posts: 18,085
Likes: 0
Received 32 Likes
on
32 Posts
Worn clutch parts, or maybe the previous owner removed the clutch "helper spring."
Edit: Sorry, I missed your comment about the helper spring being in place!
Edit: Sorry, I missed your comment about the helper spring being in place!
#6
Rennlist Member
You don't say how many miles.
When you say "helper spring in Place" Did you check to make sure it isn't broken?
I had my clutch PP, disk & TO bearing replaced on my 2003 (RMS drooling) @ ~34K. The first time I drove it I initially thought something was wrong because the clutch was so much easier to work. Turns out that as the disk wears the clutch gets harder to push. It was only worn about 1/2 way. The PO must have been pretty hard on the clutch.
When you say "helper spring in Place" Did you check to make sure it isn't broken?
I had my clutch PP, disk & TO bearing replaced on my 2003 (RMS drooling) @ ~34K. The first time I drove it I initially thought something was wrong because the clutch was so much easier to work. Turns out that as the disk wears the clutch gets harder to push. It was only worn about 1/2 way. The PO must have been pretty hard on the clutch.
#7
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
My '02 has 36K miles on it. The RMS was replaced with the previous owner at 25K. But the clutch was not replaced, and it's not a heavy duty clutch. Just the stock one.
So I have a few parts to look over... the accumulator, slave cylinder, throw-out bearing. Sounds like that would require removing the engine/transmission. I would hate to go that far, just on a suspicion of my own making. However, I will keep note of them for when the time comes.
Where is the accumulator? Is that something that can be inspected without major surgery?
Thanks for the suggestions so far.
So I have a few parts to look over... the accumulator, slave cylinder, throw-out bearing. Sounds like that would require removing the engine/transmission. I would hate to go that far, just on a suspicion of my own making. However, I will keep note of them for when the time comes.
Where is the accumulator? Is that something that can be inspected without major surgery?
Thanks for the suggestions so far.
Trending Topics
#9
Dear All,
Why is the clutch pedal pressure so hard in my '02 C4S compared to the newer cars? Everything is in good operating order, helper spring is there, etc. etc.. But when I drove my friend's 997, I couldn't believe the difference. His pedal pressure was very light, and it simply was a dream to shift. It made mine feel like an old El Camino.
Are there fundamental differences between the two? Different master cylinder, system or what? Anyone know if I can upgrade mine? I'm jealous.
Please. Don't tell me to buy a newer car. I just want to know if anyone out there ever tried anything that helped.
Thanks much,
Steve
Why is the clutch pedal pressure so hard in my '02 C4S compared to the newer cars? Everything is in good operating order, helper spring is there, etc. etc.. But when I drove my friend's 997, I couldn't believe the difference. His pedal pressure was very light, and it simply was a dream to shift. It made mine feel like an old El Camino.
Are there fundamental differences between the two? Different master cylinder, system or what? Anyone know if I can upgrade mine? I'm jealous.
Please. Don't tell me to buy a newer car. I just want to know if anyone out there ever tried anything that helped.
Thanks much,
Steve
Last edited by 10 GT3; 03-15-2010 at 10:27 PM.
#10
Three Wheelin'
It needed an RMS so I had the dealer install a new clutch kit while they were in there. It is a night and day difference.
Even at 25K, I would have replaced the clutch/bearing/pressure plate do to the fact that they are all wear items, exposed to past drivers and the age of the parts.
#11
Rennlist Member
You're a wimp? J/k
Maybe when he had the RMS work done they pinched/kinked the line getting the slave off.
get out the wrech, putter on stands and lets have at it. I think you are going to find kinked line
Maybe when he had the RMS work done they pinched/kinked the line getting the slave off.
get out the wrech, putter on stands and lets have at it. I think you are going to find kinked line
#12
I drive cars for a living, and I agree, the clutch pressure on the 996 is rather firm. I don't thnk it's very bad, but it's definitely heavier than a lot of other cars. I only have 19,000 miles on mine, and I have no clutch/transmission issues.
Do some leg-presses.
Do some leg-presses.
#14
Rennlist Member
Drive a GT3 - that's firm!
#15
I have 34K on my '02 and I was thinking the clutch took a lot of force to push. I've been trying to figure out how to measure two parameters so that we could all compare. 1) The pounds of force it takes to push in the clutch. 2) The pounds of force it takes to hold the clutch in. My little engineering pea brain says that if there is a difference between the two measurements then that is when there is a problem. Because the force to push in the clutch would be the 'back-force' from the springs and the 'friction' of physically moving all the components of the clutch system. The difference in the force measurements would be the friction component.
Also, due to a lack of freely accessable local '02 996's to compare to, being able to publish my measurements to you all would allow us to compare.
So now I need a way to take those two measurements. All I can think of so far is pushing the clutch pedal in with a broom handle on the back of my bathroom scale.
One other thing about my car that is funny is the clutch pedal makes kind of a beeping sound everytime I push it in. If I push it very slowly there is no sound. Weird, huh?
Also, due to a lack of freely accessable local '02 996's to compare to, being able to publish my measurements to you all would allow us to compare.
So now I need a way to take those two measurements. All I can think of so far is pushing the clutch pedal in with a broom handle on the back of my bathroom scale.
One other thing about my car that is funny is the clutch pedal makes kind of a beeping sound everytime I push it in. If I push it very slowly there is no sound. Weird, huh?