Are all 911s inherently unsafe?
#17
Take the car to autocross to see how it handles. Even with PSM off, the car is quite controllable, and not that easy to make the back-end break loose - of course eventually you reach the laws of physics - but with PSM on - you have to be doign something very stupid to get into trouble ,,, Understeer was much more of an issue than oversteer for me ...
#18
Instructor
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Maryland's Eastern Shore
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cars are dangerous
Having said that, I love the rear weight bias of all 911s including my current 2000 model with PSM. Driving a 911 aggressively is a challenge. Even with the chassis nanny switch on these cars can still bite. That is part of their great charm as a site like this attests.
On the other hand, I am reminded each time I drive a Boxster how much better the mid engine design is in terms of balance and tossibility at, say, 8/10ths on the street. Not that they are necessarily more fun to drive, but I'll bet I could beat my own 911's autocross times in a similarly equiped Boxster with equal power. For an amature (like myself), the Boxster is a little easier to wring speed out of quickly.
Having said that, I love the rear weight bias of all 911s including my current 2000 model with PSM. Driving a 911 aggressively is a challenge. Even with the chassis nanny switch on these cars can still bite. That is part of their great charm as a site like this attests.
On the other hand, I am reminded each time I drive a Boxster how much better the mid engine design is in terms of balance and tossibility at, say, 8/10ths on the street. Not that they are necessarily more fun to drive, but I'll bet I could beat my own 911's autocross times in a similarly equiped Boxster with equal power. For an amature (like myself), the Boxster is a little easier to wring speed out of quickly.
#19
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
All in all, I find the that I feel safer in the Porsche than I do in the other cars, simply because there isn't a lot of play in either the steering or braking. If I tell the car to do something it complies; whereas, I can fiddle with the steering in the other cars, and they won't respond in as precise a manner.
#20
Drifting
Journalists are just people in general. One that wrote for a well know motorcycle mag for years hadn't a clue about anything mechanical and would write in depth articles about the latest and greatest techno wizardly in the industry often tripping over himself and struggling all the while. It's like he'd use a press release from the manufacturer and try to reword it. Too bad he didn't get it. I lost all what little credence I had in that publication.
A neighbor of mine was the guy that did the Saturday automotive reviews for our local paper. He didn't get it either. Often he'd have me drive him up the canyons to test the latest suspension, handling or braking features. He wrote the Mitsubishi Galant sport handling control and ABS brakes without understanding what they really did. I'd pilot the car and give him a first hand demo. It amazed him as he didn't feel comfortable pushing vehicles at all. I'm sure there are a lot like this.
A neighbor of mine was the guy that did the Saturday automotive reviews for our local paper. He didn't get it either. Often he'd have me drive him up the canyons to test the latest suspension, handling or braking features. He wrote the Mitsubishi Galant sport handling control and ABS brakes without understanding what they really did. I'd pilot the car and give him a first hand demo. It amazed him as he didn't feel comfortable pushing vehicles at all. I'm sure there are a lot like this.
#21
I know this thread is more about handling safety -- but I would like to see Porsche at some point puts its cars through the same crash tests that other manufacturers do. Over the years, I've heard the 911 family is extremely safe in a crash. But I'd like to see a relative comparison.
#23
Burning Brakes
All 911s are deathtraps, you should get rid of yours right now.
As a service to all 911 owners I will take the car off your hands for no charge and give you a full release of liability. PM for details.
As a service to all 911 owners I will take the car off your hands for no charge and give you a full release of liability. PM for details.
#24
Drifting
Look at the pics, both driver and passenger lived. This happened a few miles from home and 3-4 miles below where my avatar pic was taken. They went off a steep canyon road, down a steep long embankment and I believe upside down in the icy stream.
http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=14382034
http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=14382034
#26
Rennlist Member
I know this thread is more about handling safety -- but I would like to see Porsche at some point puts its cars through the same crash tests that other manufacturers do. Over the years, I've heard the 911 family is extremely safe in a crash. But I'd like to see a relative comparison.
Here is their home page:
http://www.nhtsa.gov/
You can browse it at your leisure.
That means there are already a minimum of FIVE 991 coupes and FIVE 991 cabriolets sitting in the NHTSA junk yard out back, and results are available on their site.
Crash testing is MANDATORY. Nobody is allow to sell an automobile in the United States until NHTSA and DOT sign off on it.
#27
The engine is in the rear! Some bitch, I hadn't noticed. Really, an autocross or DE is the best learning experience you can get and calm your fears about the *** end coming around.
#28
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Thanks for all of the responses.
Don't mean to ruffle any feathers. Just asking the question from an unbiased position.
It's a bit hard to name the exact articles I have read over the years that use the 'throwing a hammer handle first' quote. I've also read terms like 'defying the laws of physics' or 'lift-off oversteer' I'm sure others have read this stuff over the years also.
Listen to this Porsche technical instructor describe the handling to Jay Leno in this video (at about 6:42 to 7:30)...
http://www.jaylenosgarage.com/video/...911-gt2/966781
I understand the argument that if the car is driven properly & within it's limits, by an adequately experienced/skilled driver, then there should be no problem, but this does not account for all situations on the road.
Other drivers, mechanical failures, dangerous road surfaces, weather condition etc. All of these external factors come into play also.
I'm not looking to buy a Volvo & understand that all mechanical designs are compromises. Just looking to get a bit more of an idea of the 996 in particular before I bother people for test-drives.
Anyhow, I think these are fascinating cars. Thanks again for all of the responses.
Don't mean to ruffle any feathers. Just asking the question from an unbiased position.
It's a bit hard to name the exact articles I have read over the years that use the 'throwing a hammer handle first' quote. I've also read terms like 'defying the laws of physics' or 'lift-off oversteer' I'm sure others have read this stuff over the years also.
Listen to this Porsche technical instructor describe the handling to Jay Leno in this video (at about 6:42 to 7:30)...
http://www.jaylenosgarage.com/video/...911-gt2/966781
I understand the argument that if the car is driven properly & within it's limits, by an adequately experienced/skilled driver, then there should be no problem, but this does not account for all situations on the road.
Other drivers, mechanical failures, dangerous road surfaces, weather condition etc. All of these external factors come into play also.
I'm not looking to buy a Volvo & understand that all mechanical designs are compromises. Just looking to get a bit more of an idea of the 996 in particular before I bother people for test-drives.
Anyhow, I think these are fascinating cars. Thanks again for all of the responses.
#29
Look at the pics, both driver and passenger lived. This happened a few miles from home and 3-4 miles below where my avatar pic was taken. They went off a steep canyon road, down a steep long embankment and I believe upside down in the icy stream.
http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=14382034
http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=14382034
#30
Rat Balls
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Scottsdale AZ, USA
Posts: 3,636
Likes: 0
Received 13 Likes
on
13 Posts
Before I owned a 996, I couldn't drive from here to there without hitting something. A tree. A curb. The occasional pedestrian. However, since I have been driving the 996, I have been accident free for over 6 months! I assume that accelerating through turns, jack rabbit starts, +100mph sprints (allegedly) and last minute braking have been handled much better by my Porsche 911 than my Jaguar XK.