Notices
Racing & Drivers Education Forum
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

Advice on a Dedicated HPDE Racecar

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 10-01-2021, 10:41 AM
  #46  
sonorous
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
 
sonorous's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Putnam County, NY
Posts: 1,074
Received 499 Likes on 234 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Quadcammer
https://www.racingjunk.com/improved-...11&from=search

factory race car is cool, no doubt.

I'm wondering though, if all you really want to do is DE, would a Cayman S with a bolt in half cage/seats/harness, GT3 style LCAs, some decent 1 or 2 way struts, upgraded brake pads, and some decent tires not do the job? Your spend would be under $60k, you'd have a fast, fun, and reliable track car that can still be used on the street in a pinch. I know safety is your priority, but given the factory safety systems built into the newer cars, I would think this package would be plenty safe.
From a functional perspective, I don't think you are wrong. A tweaked Cayman S and halo seats would probably be safe enough as well as durable and consistent. It does not really excite me however. Also, just looking around classifieds, 6cyl Cayman S cars are not that plentiful and overpriced at this current time due to the Auto market.

My wife becoming a willing participant in this hobby has really thrown a curveball into my idea of a perfect garage. My GT4 is a car that does everything I want, but honestly, these experiences with my wife transcend that. I am not going to force her to drive a manual on track just to justify the GT4. But if I look into my garage and see a GT4 and a tweaked S, guess which one I am excited to load on a trailer and drive on track? Now if you park a GTB1 car next to the GT4, that changes things significantly. I would be very excited to load up that racecar every time. This is all about being safe, having fun, learning to drive, making friends, and most of all bonding with my wife. I think we would have more fun with a racecar so if we can swing it I'd like to try to make that work. That is where my head is at right now anyway...
Old 10-01-2021, 11:03 AM
  #47  
Locker537
Instructor
 
Locker537's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 233
Received 66 Likes on 46 Posts
Default

My significant other is also not comfortable with a manual transmission, so not judgement there, but I wonder if you can rephrase it as something fun to learn and improve? With the rev matching, stability control, etc, in the GT4, it's certainly a good car to learn on compared to say, a 915 transaxle.

Cheaper to keep the car you have as well.

There is a GTB1 for sale locally...(well probably more than one).

Last edited by Locker537; 10-01-2021 at 11:11 AM.
Old 10-01-2021, 11:44 AM
  #48  
sonorous
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
 
sonorous's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Putnam County, NY
Posts: 1,074
Received 499 Likes on 234 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Locker537
My significant other is also not comfortable with a manual transmission, so not judgement there, but I wonder if you can rephrase it as something fun to learn and improve? With the rev matching, stability control, etc, in the GT4, it's certainly a good car to learn on compared to say, a 915 transaxle.

Cheaper to keep the car you have as well.

There is a GTB1 for sale locally...(well probably more than one).
Reasonable suggestion... I'd say it would be a 50/50 chance that I would be able to convince her but not sure it is worth the effort. There is an additional reason why I am hesitant. I would really like to avoid the risk of the money-shift. In the heat of battle on track with so much going on, it is fairly easy to engage the wrong gear especially for a novice that is still learning to manage all of the inputs. I have done it myself several times, not money shifting, but selecting the wrong gear. The rev-match system has secondary benefit of alerting a mis-shift with a very aggressive maximum rev match. That is enough alert to protect me from making a costly mistake but I am not sure it is for my wife. And again, I am not sure if it is worth going down that road. If we can avoid the "honey I money-shifted" conversation, I would prefer it. As much as I love driving manual on street, and like driving it on track, I would like to try PDK for a while and just focus on driving. I don't think I will miss anything. I am not hung up on needing a manual or perfecting my heel/toe. I may change my mind and come back to it but for now I am willing to forego the experience and try PDK for a while. I also plan to keep the GT4 as a mostly street car.

Every time I search for GTB1 cars, or even fully built 981's, I always seem to find good examples locally. They seem fairly easy to locate and don't see to be priced much higher than a couple years ago. At least they don't seem to be in a pricing bubble like used street cars right now...
Old 10-01-2021, 12:03 PM
  #49  
LuigiVampa
WRONGLY ACCUSED!
Rennlist Member
 
LuigiVampa's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Connecticut Valley Region
Posts: 14,517
Received 3,382 Likes on 1,621 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by sonorous
Reasonable suggestion... I'd say it would be a 50/50 chance that I would be able to convince her but not sure it is worth the effort. There is an additional reason why I am hesitant. I would really like to avoid the risk of the money-shift. In the heat of battle on track with so much going on, it is fairly easy to engage the wrong gear especially for a novice that is still learning to manage all of the inputs. I have done it myself several times, not money shifting, but selecting the wrong gear. The rev-match system has secondary benefit of alerting a mis-shift with a very aggressive maximum rev match. That is enough alert to protect me from making a costly mistake but I am not sure it is for my wife. And again, I am not sure if it is worth going down that road. If we can avoid the "honey I money-shifted" conversation, I would prefer it. As much as I love driving manual on street, and like driving it on track, I would like to try PDK for a while and just focus on driving. I don't think I will miss anything. I am not hung up on needing a manual or perfecting my heel/toe. I may change my mind and come back to it but for now I am willing to forego the experience and try PDK for a while. I also plan to keep the GT4 as a mostly street car.

Every time I search for GTB1 cars, or even fully built 981's, I always seem to find good examples locally. They seem fairly easy to locate and don't see to be priced much higher than a couple years ago. At least they don't seem to be in a pricing bubble like used street cars right now...
If your wife is interested in going to the track buy the PDK to keep her interested. A PDK car will be a ton of fun, you'll be at the track more because of it, and that is a win!

Fall into winter is an awesome time to buy a race car and there can be some good deals in the dead of winter.
Old 10-01-2021, 12:56 PM
  #50  
9eight7
Pro
 
9eight7's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2015
Posts: 726
Received 258 Likes on 182 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by sonorous
...But if I look into my garage and see a GT4 and a tweaked S, guess which one I am excited to load on a trailer and drive on track? Now if you park a GTB1 car next to the GT4, that changes things significantly. I would be very excited to load up that racecar every time...
Coming from a 987.2 to a GT4, I completely agree with your sentiment. If I were in your shoes, I would probably be 60/40 between the GTB1 and 981CS. A good hp/lb weight ratio is night and day difference between a street vs its race car version. I lean slightly towards the GTB1 as both of you could hop into racing without making adjustments if that's on the horizon. I like the 981 CS due to newer tech (I assume PDK is slightly better?) and marginal bump in HP/TQ. On fast tracks, the extra 5-10 mph on long straights feels exciting.
Old 10-01-2021, 01:24 PM
  #51  
Z-man
Race Director
 
Z-man's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: North NJ, USA
Posts: 10,170
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like on 1 Post
Default

Some good insight here, and I might as well throw in my $0.42:
First off - let's get a levelset:
1. You need a dual-driver car that is both PDK and can handle twice the load per track event.
2. You have a $100k budget. But what does that cover? Cost of the car? Car + consumables like fuel, oil, tires & brakes, + regular maintenance? Plus track fees & transportation costs? Trailer maintenance costs? Cost for storage?
3. You are an intermediate driver with a couple of years of driving experience, and your wife has a little less. How many track days have you participated in? Have you done any go-karting or autocross in the past? (I can relate to the winter roads offering you the opportunity to learn car control.... )

So, my question for you is simple: what do you want to achieve with this whole DE adventure with your bride?

Option 1: If you both want to improve your driving ability, then anything more than a moderately upgraded street car is overkill, especially at the beginner & intermediate levels.
Recommendation: A well sorted 987.2 or 981 Cayman S with a decent suspension upgrade, rollbar, harnesses, seats, and other typical track upgrades is a great choice. This is a solid platform - IMS & bore scoring issues that plagued the older Caymans & Boxster are all but gone. As you've probably experienced, these cars are the "go-to" cars for DE's. Excellent platform, well balanced, has just the right amount of power and nanny-aids to allow you to have fun in the corners yet reel you in if you step out too far. Note: the 987's have a steel body vs. the 981's aluminum skin. Sheet metal can be unbent a lot easier than aluminum.

Option 2: If you want to drive "flat out" and be the fastest car out there in DE, then get an all-out racecar. Keep in mind that your wife may not enjoy driving a stripped down, super-stiff and twitchy racecar, even with a PDK transmission. More concerning, a highly modified car hides a multitude of sins, especially in HPDE applications. Your progress will likely slow down since you will be relying on the car to go fast, vs. your developing skills.
Recommendation: While a cup car may be out of your budget, you can always build up option #1 into an all out racecar. I know that you don't want to go that route, but doing so will allow you to build up your talent to match the upgrades on your track car. Also - someone's idea of an improvement may not suit your driving style. Full disclosure: First time around, I did this with my 944S2: started bone stock, and ended with something that was one or two steps away from being a capable club level racecar. This second time around, I started with a well-sorted and modified 987.2S.

Options 3: If you want to eventually get into club racing, then a racecar in a slower class would be a good choice. If you get into a super fast class, you will be out driven and be a rolling chicane, despite your "mad driving skillz." Don't get me wrong, you are probably a good driver, but I know how this sport affects egos. If we are honest with ourselves, our ego's drive much faster than our abilities...
Recommendation: Something like a Spec Boxster, club racing spec 996/997 cup car, or a Cayman S club racer would be a good choice. Anything faster and your car will out-drive your talent.

Sorry for the long and bias-filled post. Determine what you want to achieve, and your choice will become self-evident...

Last edited by Z-man; 10-01-2021 at 03:34 PM.
Old 10-01-2021, 02:29 PM
  #52  
9eight7
Pro
 
9eight7's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2015
Posts: 726
Received 258 Likes on 182 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Z-man
...You are an intermediate drive with a couple of years of driving experience, and your wife has a little less. ...
Option 1: If you both want to improve your driving ability, then anything more than a moderately upgraded street car is overkill, especially at the beginner & intermediate levels.
Recommendation: A well sorted 987.2 or 981 Cayman S with a decent suspension upgrade, rollbar, harnesses, seats, and other typical track upgrades is a great choice. This is a solid platform - IMS & bore scoring issues that plagued the older Caymans & Boxster are all but gone. As you've probably experienced, these cars are the "go-to" cars for DE's. Excellent platform, well balanced, has just the right amount of power and nanny-aids to allow you to have fun in the corners yet reel you in if you step out too far. Note: the 987's have a steel body vs. the 981's aluminum skin. Sheet metal can be unbent a lot easier than aluminum...
I completely forgot to take experience into account. I agree, I like option 1 best.
Old 10-01-2021, 03:44 PM
  #53  
sonorous
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
 
sonorous's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Putnam County, NY
Posts: 1,074
Received 499 Likes on 234 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Z-man
Some good insight here, and I might as well throw in my $0.42:
This whole thread has been a great dialog and I appreciate all of the comments and suggestions, thanks...

Originally Posted by Z-man
First off - let's get a levelset:
1. You need a dual-driver car that is both PDK and can handle twice the load per track event.
2. You have a $100k budget. But what does that cover? Cost of the car? Car + consumables like fuel, oil, tires & brakes, + regular maintenance? Plus track fees & transportation costs? Trailer maintenance costs? Cost for storage?
3. You are an intermediate drive with a couple of years of driving experience, and your wife has a little less. How many track days have you participated in? Have you done any go-karting or autocross in the past? (I can related to the winter roads offering you the opportunity to learn car control.... )
1. Correct
2. I learned on RL that it is bad practice to add it all up So we will stick with a 100k vehicle budget
3. 18 days for me and 16 for my wife plus we each have attended one day high performance driving school with car control (manufacturer based). We are both attending a car control clinic at LRP next weekend. I want her to have improved control so that she can handle herself when she gets in trouble pushing her car. For me I just like drifting on the skidpad and there is never too much car control skill!

Originally Posted by Z-man
So, my question for you is simple: what do you want to achieve with this whole DE adventure with your bride?

Option 1: If you both want to improve your driving ability, then anything more than a moderately upgraded street car is overkill, especially at the beginner & intermediate levels.
Recommendation: A well sorted 987.2 or 981 Cayman S with a decent suspension upgrade, rollbar, harnesses, seats, and other typical track upgrades is a great choice. This is a solid platform - IMS & bore scoring issues that plagued the older Caymans & Boxster are all but gone. As you've probably experienced, these cars are the "go-to" cars for DE's. Excellent platform, well balanced, has just the right amount of power and nanny-aids to allow you to have fun in the corners yet reel you in if you step out too far. Note: the 987's have a steel body vs. the 981's aluminum skin. Sheet metal can be unbent a lot easier than aluminum.

Option 2: If you want to drive "flat out" and be the fastest car out there in DE, then get an all-out racecar. Keep in mind that your wife may not enjoy driving a stripped down, super-stiff and twitchy racecar, even with a PDK transmission. More concerning, a highly modified car hides a multitude of sins, especially in HPDE applications. Your progress will likely slow down since you will be relying on the car to go fast, vs. your developing skills.
Recommendation: While a cup car may be out of your budget, you can always build up option #1 into an all out racecar. I know that you don't want to go that route, but doing so will allow you to build up your talent to match the upgrades on your track car. Also - someone's idea of an improvement may not suit your driving style. Full disclosure: First time around, I did this with my 944S2: started bone stock, and ended with something that was one or two steps away from being a capable club level racecar. This second time around, I started with a well-sorted and modified 987.2S.

Options 3: If you want to eventually get into club racing, then a racecar in a slower class would be a good choice. If you get into a super fast class, you will be out driven and be a rolling chicane, despite your "mad driving skillz." Don't get me wrong, you are probably a good driver, but I know how this sport affects egos. If we are honest with ourselves, our ego's drive much faster than our abilities...
Recommendation: Something like a Spec Boxster, club racing spec 996/997 cup car, or a Cayman S club racer would be a good choice. Anything faster and your car will out-drive your talent.

Sorry for the long and bias-filled post. Determine what you want to achieve, and your choice will become self-evident...
If I had to pick one of your options, it would be Option 1. However, with DE I think part of the component that makes it fun is an exciting car, at least for my wife and I. She took a ride in a GTB1 car at the last DE and really liked it. I will ask her if the gutted interior bothers her. It is worth checking. A Cayman S is great and the smart choice but it lacks fizz for me. I may get there but thinking about a racecar is exciting.

And I do really try to check my ego at the door for anything DE related. I think I am a quick driver for my experience, but I know my place. When I ride with an instructor I am humbled and inspired every time. I am usually one of the fastest drivers in my run group with my GT4. I was one of the slowest in the rented Miata.

Does anyone want to take an OT sidebar and criticize my driving? I'll sacrifice my ego and throw a video out on the line for the sake of this discussion. I know there are a lot of very skilled and experienced drivers on here. Here is my best lap at Palmer CCW in my rented Miata. A few disclaimers... This car was quite long in the tooth, a 1990 with 150k miles, on 200TW tires, and since it was a T30 class car I assume mostly stock and therefore only ~116hp. This is also my first time ever driving on track without auto-blip and I am not good at heel and toe. I struggled mostly with entry into turns 1, 4 and 9 because of this. With some googling it seems that this same car won a time trial 5 years ago with a 2:57.xx at Palmer so that is my benchmark as a fast lap. I have a little work to do before I can say I mastered the Miata.

Old 10-01-2021, 04:53 PM
  #54  
911 Rod
Race Car
 
911 Rod's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Terrorizing your neighbourhood!
Posts: 4,332
Received 290 Likes on 198 Posts
Default

What happens when you and your wife are in the same run group?

She's okay with being in a race car that beats you up as much as you beat it up?
Old 10-01-2021, 05:04 PM
  #55  
sonorous
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
 
sonorous's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Putnam County, NY
Posts: 1,074
Received 499 Likes on 234 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by 911 Rod
What happens when you and your wife are in the same run group?
Valid question... The theory is that we never will be but it is possible. My pace is much faster than her and I have been promoted at a much faster rate. She continues to surprise me however. I guess we will deal with that if it happens. I know a few people that share cars and it can work.
Originally Posted by 911 Rod
She's okay with being in a race car that beats you up as much as you beat it up?
Again, she continues to surprise me. We have been married for 24 year and if you asked me if she would ever DE a few years ago, I would say absolutely not... So we are in uncharted waters here! I know what I am getting into with a race car. That Miata beat me up but I kind of like to be beat up. I will discuss this concern with her.
Old 10-02-2021, 10:07 AM
  #56  
MSR Racer
Rennlist Member
 
MSR Racer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Mid-South
Posts: 1,196
Received 180 Likes on 109 Posts
Default

Increase your budget and buy a cayman club sport or retired GT4 spec race car. Or MX 5 cup Miata.
Your budget is insufficient to meet all your requirements in a modern track or race car realistically. Don’t touch old cups, 996/997. They will sink you. Slicks are overkill for DEs and they peak at 2-3 laps and fall off.
Also, be very circumspect in buying shop or individually built / developed street conversions. Most are high school science experiments. I have had them all…conversions, cups, factory built race cars etc.

Last edited by MSR Racer; 10-02-2021 at 10:12 AM.
Old 10-03-2021, 12:08 PM
  #57  
cobradvm
Intermediate
 
cobradvm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Posts: 45
Received 19 Likes on 12 Posts
Default

If not already suggested, I would save a decent percentage of your budget for professional instruction - it will be worth far more than if you spent that $$$ on the car.
The following 2 users liked this post by cobradvm:
Dr911 (10-11-2021), sonorous (10-03-2021)
Old 10-11-2021, 11:25 AM
  #58  
txbdan
Rennlist Member
 
txbdan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2019
Location: MA
Posts: 550
Received 171 Likes on 114 Posts
Default

The issue here is the need for DCT/PDK. That puts you in a whole different realm of cost and speed. You have a $100k budget, but is that budget going to good use if it gets a car that's way over your heads and costs a fortune to maintain?

It is a good point to make the wife happy and engaged the highest priority, but if she's at all open to driving a manual, it'd open a lot of platforms that would be better learning platforms with far lower initial and running costs. The answer is always Miata of course, but if that's no fun, E46s 330s (like a SpecE46) are a tremendous value, easy to drive, and very safe.

My wife is tinkering on the edge of doing a track day. If/When she's ready we're going track-prepped Miata shopping.
Old 10-11-2021, 07:34 PM
  #59  
T&T Racing
Rennlist Member
 
T&T Racing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: New York & Indiana
Posts: 2,876
Received 339 Likes on 271 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by txbdan
The issue here is the need for DCT/PDK. That puts you in a whole different realm of cost and speed. You have a $100k budget, but is that budget going to good use if it gets a car that's way over your heads and costs a fortune to maintain?

It is a good point to make the wife happy and engaged the highest priority, but if she's at all open to driving a manual, it'd open a lot of platforms that would be better learning platforms with far lower initial and running costs. The answer is always Miata of course, but if that's no fun, E46s 330s (like a SpecE46) are a tremendous value, easy to drive, and very safe.

My wife is tinkering on the edge of doing a track day. If/When she's ready we're going track-prepped Miata shopping.
Best to start with the the platforms you mentioned.
In perspective, Mark Donahue, Roger Penske, PL Newman started in low horsepower race cars and translated to faster race cars. Do you want to experience the history of racing with manual transmission and no ABS or do you want to be someone in which the car drives you vs the one who drives the car. Be humble for there are so many newbies who think they are auto racers in PDK race cars. Be better than them
Old 10-11-2021, 08:03 PM
  #60  
Dr911
Burning Brakes
 
Dr911's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 957
Received 6 Likes on 6 Posts
Default

Hi OP!

Both as an instructor and as a driver, I can vouch for the step-down to a less powerful car as the way to go to advance your skill-set (and your wife's) to the Black-Red run group competence level.
A Miata isn't really the most fun you can have at a PCA track day (speaking from experience) but ... you may find that a Boxster is the "sweet spot" you're looking for.
I just posted my turnkey *newly built* Spec Boxster for sale on this forum, but there are plenty of used SPB's out there to find as well.

And while a Boxster might a bit 'less car' than the earlier thoughts around a GTB1 car, you may wish to consider that the lower tag allows students to dedicate more resources toward coaching, track support, and more track days/ seat time.

As sometimes I've heard coaches say ... "tuning the nut behind the wheel" can be the most powerful "track mod" out there!
Best wishes...and so happy you both are enjoying the sport as a couple!


Quick Reply: Advice on a Dedicated HPDE Racecar



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 01:24 PM.